Valentine's Day was just around the corner when President Trump and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi came together for a pivotal meeting, casting a hopeful light on the diplomatic landscape. Known for his supportive gestures towards Trump, Modi arrived with high hopes of navigating around the hefty tariffs recently imposed on various countries. But was the atmosphere filled with genuine camaraderie, or was Modi simply being cautious? What implications does this meeting have for the future trajectory of Indo-U.S. relations?
## The Contrasting Themes: MIGA vs. MAGA
One of the intriguing contrasts is between Modi's determination to “Make India Great Again” (MIGA) and Trump’s widely recognized slogan “Make America Great Again” (MAGA). This fascinating dynamic merits further exploration.
### Why Did Trump Call Modi the "Tariff King"?
Even before finalizing the latest round of tariffs, President Trump made it clear that he intended to challenge India's trade practices. He dubbed Modi's country the “tariff king” multiple times, setting the stage for a fiery debate on trade relations.
The White House recently issued a statement emphasizing the need for fairer trade practices, highlighting that the average U.S. tariff on agricultural goods is merely 5% for countries that hold Most Favored Nation (MFN) status. In sharp contrast, India's average applied MFN tariff stands at a staggering 39%. Additionally, the document revealed, “India imposes a hefty 100% tariff on U.S. motorcycles, while the tariff we charge on Indian motorcycles is only 2.4%.”
Trump has already implemented an additional 10% tariff on Chinese imports, citing concerns over the production of fentanyl, which has fueled an overdose crisis in America. Plans are also underway to impose tariffs on Canada and Mexico—America’s two largest trading partners—which could take effect in March after a 30-day suspension. In a decisive move, Trump lifted exemptions from the steel and aluminum tariffs he established back in 2018, tightening the trade landscape even further.
## What Was New Delhi’s Response?
In a strategic counter-move, New Delhi expressed its willingness to increase purchases of American oil while reducing its own tariffs on U.S. products. Specifically, the tariffs on certain Harley-Davidson motorcycles were cut from 50% to 40%, showcasing a proactive approach even before Modi's visit to Washington.
Additionally, in 2023, India took notable steps by eliminating retaliatory tariffs on a range of American products, including almonds, apples, chickpeas, lentils, and walnuts. These moves underline India’s commitment to strengthening trade ties with the U.S. amidst the complexities of international relations.
## Understanding Reciprocal Tariffs
Trump's tough stance on foreign imports isn't limited to India; he has also imposed tariffs on China and is preparing to apply similar measures to the European Union, while still eyeing Canada and Mexico as potential targets. By signing off on what he calls “reciprocal” tariffs, the White House aims to level the competitive playing field between U.S. manufacturers and foreign competitors. However, these new tariffs are likely to ultimately burden American consumers and businesses directly or through elevated prices.
In 2023, the Indo-U.S. trade in goods and services reached approximately $190.1 billion. According to India’s External Affairs Ministry, U.S. exports to India amounted to nearly $70 billion, while imports were around $120 billion. Although the U.S. is India’s largest trade partner, the trade deficit stands at $50 billion in India’s favor.
Clearly, Trump is exploring every avenue to bring order to trade relations—an ambitious undertaking indeed.
## What Was Discussed During PM Modi’s Visit?
When Trump and Modi met, they shared a warm embrace in the lobby of the West Wing before moving to the Oval Office for their discussions. Trump described Modi as a “great friend,” echoing sentiments just hours after signing new tariffs. “We share a great friendship, both personally and between our countries, and I believe it’s only going to get closer,” Trump stated.
Among the key outcomes was a deal that allows U.S.-based General Electric to collaborate with Hindustan Aeronautics in producing jet engines for Indian aircraft. Additionally, the sale of U.S.-made armed MQ-9B SeaGuardian drones and a review of the US-India Initiative on Critical and Emerging Technology (ICET) were also on the agenda, setting the stage for continuing cooperation established under the Biden administration.
A Trump administration official, who spoke on condition of anonymity, remarked that India has taken positive steps in trade discussions, with a goal of finalizing a fair trade arrangement by year’s end.
Immigration also featured prominently in the talks, with Trump expected to urge India to accept back thousands of undocumented immigrants. Modi became the fourth foreign leader to meet with Trump since his inauguration last month, following meetings with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Japan's Ishiba, and Jordan’s King Abdullah II.
Before meeting Trump, Modi had discussions with national security advisor Mike Waltz and even connected with billionaire SpaceX founder and top Trump advisor, Elon Musk.
For the Trump administration, India is seen as a crucial player in its strategy to counteract China's influence in the Indo-Pacific region. Modi’s nation is set to host a Quad summit later this year with the U.S., India, Japan, and Australia.
Furthermore, Modi held discussions with Tulsi Gabbard, Trump’s newly appointed director of national intelligence, focusing on enhancing cooperation in counterterrorism and cybersecurity.
## Navigating Tensions: India’s Balancing Act
Modi harbors concerns that Trump could potentially strike a deal with China that may sideline India, a sentiment echoed by Mukesh Aghi, president of the U.S.-India Strategic Partnership Forum. During their meeting, Trump expressed his eagerness to assist in resolving ongoing tensions along the India-China border.
Amidst these complexities, India has maintained its ties with Russia throughout its ongoing conflict with Ukraine, remaining a significant consumer of Russian energy while Western countries have sought to reduce their consumption since the war began.
As India walks a tightrope in its relationship with the U.S., Trump seeks more concessions in exchange for support. How will these dynamics evolve in the months ahead?
What influence will issues like immigration, tariffs, and India’s relationship with Russia have on this bilateral relationship? How might India's position assist the U.S. in addressing the China factor? We invite you to share your thoughts in the comments section. Do you consider Modi's trip a success?
As we navigate this complex world of international relations, your insights are invaluable. Thank you for staying engaged!
Comments